website statistics

Myriad Genetics, a leading biotech firm, has been fighting a legal battle to gain permission to patent isolated genes. Now, a court has ruled in its favor.
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (Rate This)
Loading...

For long, biotech firms have been trying to have human genes declared patentable. The reasons for such ambitions are obvious – these biotech firms spend millions of dollars to isolate genes and find cures to diseases. And although they earn many time more than the amount they spend, they want to lay their hands on even more. A new court ruling now seems to have sided with them.


The ruling has been given by U.S. appeals court and applies to the legal feud over patenting BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes related to breast cancer. Myriad Genetics has been aggressively pursuing a legal battle to have these genes patentable. And in this, it was bitterly opposed by a group of medical organizations, headed by American Civil Liberties Union and Public Patent Foundation (PUBPAT).

The case has been fought off by these two sides since a long time and now, the appeals court has ruled that patents on genes are valid “because each of the claimed molecules represents a nonnaturally occurring composition of matter.” To be clear, the court refers to isolated DNA extracted from cells during the course of a research as ‘nonnaturally occurring matter.’

However, the court also ruled that Myriad Genetics’ claims on testing cancer risk by analyzing DNA sequences is not patentable because it is rather based on “abstract, mental steps of logic that are not “transformative.”

Naturally, neither the Myriad Genetics nor the group of medical organizations appears happy with this verdict. The co-counsel against Myriad, Dan Ravicher, had stated earlier, “Human genes are not like new genetic tools or drugs, which can be patented because they are manufactured. It is absurd to think that a company can own naturally-occurring human genes simply because they removed them from the body.”

This argument is the cornerstone of the opposition to the claim that genes can be patented. Such a move, medical organizations argue, can seriously undermine research in the field of medicine, effectively putting it in the hands of rich, profit-making biotech firms.

For now, PUBPAT is considering the verdict and planning its next move. According to PUBPAT’s attorney, the group hasn’t “made any final decisions about what we’ll do. … But we are not satisfied with this result, and think the dissenting judge in the Court of Appeals decision today is correct that isolated human genes are not patentable.”

Source: WSJ

Buy Cheapest Related Product From Amazon.com


Scientists Baffled Over Sun’s Almost Perfectly Round Shape

D-Link Amplifi Cloud Router 5700 (DIR-865L)
You can also press the left/right arrow key on your keyboard to go to previous/next post
  On August 18, 2012(3 years, 9 months ago.)

You May Also Like:

What Do You Think?

Leave a Reply




Loading Facebook Comments ...

FTC Disclosure: Some of the links of this website are "affiliate links." This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, we will receive an affiliate commission.


Recent Search

Recent Tutorials

Even if your iPhone is locked, people can reply from the lock screen. Check out, how to turn off the quick reply message from locked screen.
Have you forgot Apple ID password or having trouble signing in? Check out this tutorial to reset the password.
Even if iPhone is muted, still Siri's voice is loudly chime. Now you can change the setting to silence Siri using your iPhone's mute switch.
Check out how to teach Siri about nicknames and relationships of the important people in your life in order to make your life easier.
Has your iPhone suddenly turned black & white? Check out this tutorial to know possible reasons & how to fix iPhone screen with few taps.
Check out this tutorial to download FREE movies and TV Shows streaming Showbox app and install it on your Android smartphone or tablet.
Parental Controls allows you to put restrictions on apps or content that can or can not be used by anyone else on your Apple iPhone or iPad.
If you want to print from iPhone without using any computer, check this out to connect and print wirelessly right from the Apple device.
Using Siri, anyone can bypass the Passcode even if iPhone or iPad is locked. Check out this to know how you can disable Siri on lock screen.
Floatify will let you quick reply to the messages or emails through notification bar using your Android Lollipop or Marshmallow.
Close You Have To Login
User:
Pass:
Login With »Login With TwitterLogin With Facebook