website statistics

Since as far back as 1908, the 'first-sale' doctrine has been recognized widely, admitting that if you purchase something legally, you have the right to sell it to someone else. In 1998, Supreme Court in U.S. ruled, in extension of the first-sale doctrine, that even if the sale of a product took place outside U.S., if it was made and sold in U.S., it will still be subject to first-sale rule.
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (Rate This)
Loading...

Since as far back as 1908, the ‘first-sale’ doctrine has been recognized widely, admitting that if you purchase something legally, you have the right to sell it to someone else. In 1998, Supreme Court in U.S. ruled, in extension of the first-sale doctrine, that even if the sale of a product took place outside U.S., if it was made and sold in U.S., it will still be subject to first-sale rule.


However, now, a case currently under process has put the entire philosophy of first-sale into question and can pose a lot of problems to the consumers of different products.

The case in question is about a student who was receiving books from his relatives outside of U.S. The books were sold for much less in his relatives’ country, so essentially it was a cheaper way for him to access the books rather than purchasing them in U.S. The publisher of the books in question, John Wiley & Sons, felt that it was being ‘swindled’ and thus, took the student to court.

A New York federal court ruled in favor of the publisher stating that such products which were made outside of U.S. were not subject to first-sale doctrine, clearly a violation of the 1998 SC ruling.

And things don’t just end there. This poses a great dilemma to consumer electronics users because these days, most of these products are manufactured in China, something which is explicitly stated. So by the NY Federal Court’s ruling, selling an iPad made in China, to a friend in U.S. may become illegal all of a sudden.

Naturally, that’s an absurd and rather stupid stance and we can only hope that now that the case has been appealed to the Supreme Court, the court will undo the damage done and stop such a thing from happening.

Source: The Atlantic

Courtesy: Cult of Mac


Opera 12 Debuts With Camera Support

According To Reports, Windows RT License Will Cost $85
You can also press the left/right arrow key on your keyboard to go to previous/next post
  On June 14, 2012(3 years, 11 months ago.)

You May Also Like:

What Do You Think?

Leave a Reply




Loading Facebook Comments ...

FTC Disclosure: Some of the links of this website are "affiliate links." This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, we will receive an affiliate commission.


Recent Search

Recent Tutorials

If you're still struggling to take selfie on iPhone then check it out to know how to take photos from far using iPhone's headset as a remote.
Even if your iPhone is locked, people can reply from the lock screen. Check out, how to turn off the quick reply message from locked screen.
Have you forgot Apple ID password or having trouble signing in? Check out this tutorial to reset the password.
Even if iPhone is muted, still Siri's voice is loudly chime. Now you can change the setting to silence Siri using your iPhone's mute switch.
Check out how to teach Siri about nicknames and relationships of the important people in your life in order to make your life easier.
Has your iPhone suddenly turned black & white? Check out this tutorial to know possible reasons & how to fix iPhone screen with few taps.
Check out this tutorial to download FREE movies and TV Shows streaming Showbox app and install it on your Android smartphone or tablet.
Parental Controls allows you to put restrictions on apps or content that can or can not be used by anyone else on your Apple iPhone or iPad.
If you want to print from iPhone without using any computer, check this out to connect and print wirelessly right from the Apple device.
Using Siri, anyone can bypass the Passcode even if iPhone or iPad is locked. Check out this to know how you can disable Siri on lock screen.
Close You Have To Login
User:
Pass:
Login With »Login With TwitterLogin With Facebook